- San Diego
- Cleveland – Neftali Barrios 2B
Great power. Good contact. Can drive the ball well. Has great knowledge of the strike zone. Good speed. Good glove, average range, weak arm. Durable.
hurricane384 on Barrios:
This guy is ready for the bigs right now…given time to develop he could definitely become an MVP candidate. Best position will likely be LF.
Owner abesmem says:
- Washington – Raymond Small RHP
Good control. Good stamina. Durability worries. Great against RHB. Above average against LHB. Decent at inducing GBs. 2 good pitches. 2 above average pitches. 1 average pitch. Decent velocity.
hurricane384 on Small:
Although I’d be worried about his durability affecting his ability to pitch in more than 33 or so games, he still has the stuff of an Ace and that makes this a very good pick.
Owner hamilton44 says:
- Cincinnati – Humberto Posada LF
Great power. Great contact. Dominant against RHP. Great knowledge of the strike zone. Average speed. Above average durability. Poor defensively.
hopkinsheel on Posada:
Looks like the best “pure” hitter in the draft. Should be an all star for many seasons. Will hit for average and power and could lead the world in OPS. Great pick at #5.
Owner hurricane384 says:
This was our #1 guy. He’s more of a 1B, but that doesn’t really matter since he can hit so well. This pick makes the organization very excited for his development.
- New Orleans: Rich Coco RF
Good power. Good contact. Better against RHP than LHP. Great eye. Good speed. Great range for a RF. Good durability.
hurricane384 on Coco:
This is a nice pick, he’s not going to put up MVP numbers, but should definitely be good enough to help this team offensively in 2-3 years. Could play now if needed.
Owner Weena says:
- Chicago (AL)
- Houston: Ignacio Polanco LHP
Great control. Great fastball. Good change. Above average slider. Does a nice job of keeping the hitters off-balance. Durable. Below average stamina.
hurricane384 on Polanco:
A nice pick, Polanco may be destined to be a super reliever with his low stamina and only having 3 pitches. He does have 3 good pitches though.
Owner drichar138 says:
- Arizona: Jim Schafer RF
Plus contact. Above average power. Good splits. Great eye. Good durability. Good speed. Weak arm for RF. Good range and glove.
hurricane384 on Schafer:
Schafer should be able to hold down the #2 spot in the lineup for Arizona. He should hit about 25-30 HRs a season, and have an OBP of .380 or better.
Owner The__Kid says:
Very happy to get my 3rd ranked hitter with the #10 pick. Jim Schafer projects to be a 1B of LF with some speed. A great #2 hitter.
- Florida – Carl Marte SS
Great defensively. Average contact. Average power. Better against LHP. Great speed. Great durability. Good eye.
hurricane384 on Marte:
With this draft being so top-heavy, anytime you can grab a SS who isn’t going to be an offensive black hole while playing gold glove caliber defense, you have to do it.
Owner cnsmuck says:
- Detroit: Pat Palmer RHP
Great stamina. Good control. Keeps hitters guessing. Above average velocity. Great GB pitcher. Above average fastball and 3 average pitches.
hurricane384 on Palmer:
Picking 13th, you don’t normally expect a pitcher of this caliber to be around. He can be a good #2 for years for Detroit.
Owner Arte says:
- St. Louis: Mark Prince RHP
Good control. Average splits. Great velocity. Great durability. Good stamina. Adept at groundballs. Great sinker. Good changeup and slider.
hurricane384 on Prince:
The splits worry me as does the fact that he is a starter with only 3 pitches, but everything else seems good, so he should develop into a good player.
Owner dwboyce says:
After much time, we settled on Prince, hoping that his stellar control, velocity, his ability to induce a ground ball and the movement on his pitches would offset his mediocre effectiveness that perhaps we were underestimating.
- Los Angeles: Donnie McInerney C
Above average defensively. Above average game caller. Great contact. Above average power. Drives the ball well. Above average eye. Great durability.
hurricane384 on McInerney:
In a catching poor world, it’s hard to believe that he dropped so far. Any time you can get a catcher who can appear in 140+ games and post a .300/.370/.500 line, you have to do it. Great pick.
Owner rawdk27 says: When our pick came up in the 1st round we were totally caught off guard that Donnie McInerney was still on the Vin Cueto . The room was divided and with 10 seconds left on the clock our GM flipped a coin. Tails it was and Donnie was our pick. Looking back on it and having Frank Hunter in the fold already, with the bullpen being a strong need, Cueto should have been our guy.
- Anaheim: Rey Sowders C
Above average defensively. Above average game caller. Good contact. Poor power. Decent splits. Great eye. Great durability.
hurricane384 on Sowders:
Although he might not look like much, he should be able to catch nearly every game for Anaheim while posting a .375 OBP. Not bad for a C.
Owner allright says:
- New York (AL)
- Montreal – Bret Roosevelt CF
Good defensively. Great durability. Decent speed. Great power. Will strike out…A LOT. Above average eye. Average against LHP. Weak against RHP.
hurricane384 on Roosevelt:
This is a great pick at this stage in the game. Montreal gets a player who will be able to hold down CF defensively, and he will provide a lot of power to go along with it.
- Baltimore: Vin Cueto LHP
Great control. Dominant pitches. Great durability. Weak stamina. Poor velocity. Great against LHB and RHB.
hurricane384 on Cueto:
When you have a pitcher who is going to post a WHIP of less than 1.00, it’s hard to find anything to complain about. This is a great spot for 1-inning closer.
Owner hopkinsheel says:
Cueto was ranked 5th on our board so we were pleased to snag him at pick #20. This is the least amount we’ve ever budgeted in the amateur draft so we weren’t sure what to expect.Hopefully we can invest more next season. With Cueto’s combination of great splits and two plus pitches, Cueto will be tabbed our closer of the future.
- Chicago (NL): Kenny Kulik LHP
Great control. 1 good pitch. 1 average pitch. 3 average pitches. Decent stamina. Great durability. Great velocity.
hurricane384 on Kulik:
A tough pick here as I simply do not like the splits. He might do well, but I’d be a little suprised if he were any more than a long reliever. The pitches might make up for his splits.
Owner tk21775 says: Kulik was rated #8 on our draft board so we were happy to grab him with the #21 pick. With his durability/stamina combo he can help out in either the starting rotation or long relief, has great control and decent splits. There wasn’t a lot of depth at pitching this draft but we were glad to add a lefty into our farm system.
- Seattle – Danny Lee CF
Good defense. Decent durability. Good speed. Great contact. Below average power. Average against LHP. Good against RHP. Good eye.
hurricane384 on Lee:
This is a good pick. Should be able to play good defense and be one of the best lead-off hitters in the league.
- Anaheim: Brad Hinchliffe SS
Tremendous defensively. Great speed. Great durability. Above average at making contact. Poor power. Struggles against average pitching. Poor eye.
hurricane384 on Hinchliffe:
This is a hard pick to quibble with as he picked up a nearly dominant defensive SS who won’t kill a team offensively.
Owner allright says:
- Chicago (NL)
Owner tk21775 says: Presley was our 11th choice and got him with the 24th pick. We thought he would drop down to us as his overall isn’t very solid but we think it has to do with his defense. He’ll be good enough defensively to play 1B for us and has a solid bat all the way around. Very happy to add a quality bat like Presley’s down this far in the draft.
- Pittsburgh: Glenn Lowry LHP
Good durability. Decent stamina. Very good control. Very good against LHP. Good against RHP. Very good velocity. 3 good pitches. 1 average pitch. 1 poor pitch.
hurricane384 on Lowry:
He’s a solid pitcher, who can hold his own as a starter or a reliever. Should develop into a solid #3 member of the rotation.
Owner ajwalton says:
- Kansas City: Nipsey Baez SS
Exceptional defender. Good durability. Good speed. Below average offensively with the exception of his knowledge of the strike zone and effectiveness against LHP.
hurricane384 on Baez:
Another good defensive SS who is not going to be a black hole offensively.
Owner bighead34 says: Kansas City was very happy to draft Nipsey. We had him ranked around #10. He profiles as an elite defender at SS. His bat projects to be at least average for the position. He will also be able to add value on the basepaths. We believe he has the talent to be an everyday player on a contending team.
- Montreal – Howard Coghlan RF
Good defense. Very durable. Above average speed. Good power. Good contact. Average splits. average eye.
hurricane384 on Coghlan:
He’s a good pick. At this point in the 1st round, you’re looking for guys who can contribute to the team’s success, and Howard will definitely do that. He’s not going to be a superstar, but he’ll be a good player.
- New York (NL): Donzell Root LF
Good power. Good average. Good against LHP. Average against RHP. Good eye. Durable. Decent defense.
hurricane384 on Root: A true testament to the scouting department of the Mets, Root has the ability to be a very good LF/1B offensively and a gold glove 1B.
nymetman says: My scouts were drawn to Root’s combination of power, speed and durability. We anticipate him progressing into a perennial 35 HR/15 SB threat. Very pleased that he dropped to us so late in the 1st round.
- Atlanta – Akinori Zhang RHP
Good durability. Great stamina. Good splits. No velocity. Great at inducing groundballs. 1 great pitch. 2 good pitches. 2 average pitches.
hurricane384 on Zhang:
I love this pick. Zhang, in my opinion, has a legit shot at being a #1 pitcher in Atlanta’s rotation and to get that with the 29th pick is awesome.
Owner kilgore says:
- Chicago (AL) –
- Florida – Lawrence Walker 3B
Average range. Average glove. Strong arm. Average contact. Average power. Good against LHP. Average against RHP. Poor eye.
hurricane384 on Walker:
Not a bad pick, not a great pick. It is a solid pick for this area. He’s a useful player who won’t embarrass his team.
Owner cnsmuck says:
- Toronto: George Wright SS
Good power. Average contact. Average against RHP. Above average against LHP. Good eye. Poor defense. Good durability. Good speed.
hurricane384 on Wright:
No way does he stay at SS with his defensive ratings. He’s not going to be a top 5 player at any position, but he definitely could hold down the fort at either CIF, COF, or even 2B.
Owner mitchrapp says: